Cod Liver Oil Capsules and Tablets: How to Choose the Best One
Cod liver oil capsules are the only form on this shelf: every product here is a capsule or softgel, including the ones sold as cod liver oil tablets. This page explains what high strength means on a label, and how much vitamin A one capsule can carry against the NHS limit of 1.5mg (1,500 micrograms) a day from food and supplements. It also covers why the NHS says not to take cod liver oil in pregnancy, and how it compares with fish oil.
Choose a one-a-day capsule that prints EPA and DHA in milligrams per capsule and states its vitamin A, rather than going by the 1000mg or high strength on the front, which describes the oil. On listings that give the figure, EPA plus DHA runs from 170mg to 400mg per capsule. If you are pregnant or trying for a baby, do not take cod liver oil: the NHS advises avoiding it because of its vitamin A.
Our shortlist
These are the products on this shelf we would start with, each for a different reason. Every one links to our full research page.
Zipvit Cod Liver Oil 1000mg, 120 Softgels. EPA 80mg DHA
The one we would buy. It states 80mg EPA and 90mg DHA per capsule on the front rather than hiding behind the 1000mg figure, which in this category is a genuine mark of confidence. The dose is one capsule a day. Our BasketLab score of 4.1 is the highest in the category.
Read our research →Zipvit Cod Liver Oil 1000mg, 120 Softgel Capsules, Rich in
The same 1000mg, 120-softgel format from a familiar UK supplements brand at a lower price. If you're taking one a day for months, the per-capsule difference adds up faster than the brand difference matters. Check the EPA and DHA figures against the pick above before deciding they're equivalent.
Read our research →Natures Aid Cod Liver Oil 550mg
550mg rather than 1000mg, which sounds like less and is the sensible choice for anyone who eats oily fish regularly and wants a top-up rather than a full replacement. Natures Aid is long-established in UK health food shops.
Read our research →MÖLLER'S Moller’s ® | Cod Liver Oil Capsules | Omega
Møller's has been making cod liver oil in Norway since the 1850s, which is the kind of provenance that matters more in this category than most, because oil freshness and sourcing are the real quality variables. It costs more than the own-label options, and that's what you're paying for.
Read our research →Zipvit Cod Liver Oil 1000mg, 360 Capsules of High Strength
360 capsules, so a year at one a day. Cod liver oil keeps well stored cool and dark, which makes bulk buying sensible here in a way it's not for everything. Work out the per-capsule cost against the 120 pack before assuming the bigger box wins.
Read our research →WeightWorld Antarctic Krill Oil Capsules - 1200mg - 3 Months
Krill oil rather than cod liver oil: omega-3 in phospholipid form, often claimed to absorb better. We include it because people cross-shop the two, not because we think the absorption claim justifies the price. Per milligram of EPA and DHA it's the dearest option here.
Read our research →Cod liver oil capsules, tablets or liquid: which form to buy
Cod liver oil capsules are the form to buy in the UK, simply because softgel capsules are what the shelf sells. A softgel holds a measured dose, hides the taste and keeps air away from the oil until you swallow it.
On this shelf, cod liver oil tablets are softgels by another name. Sellers use tablets, pills and capsules for the same thing: SuperSelf, for example, sells its cod liver oil as 60 softgel tablets. Compare them exactly as you would any capsule.
Capsule size follows the fill. A 500mg or 550mg capsule holds roughly half the oil of a 1000mg one and is usually the smaller softgel, which helps if large capsules are hard to swallow. One example is Hellenia Cod Liver Oil 500mg, taken at one capsule a day.
Liquid cod liver oil is taken by the spoon, and a 5ml teaspoon holds several times the oil in a 1000mg capsule. That means several times the vitamin A as well, which matters for the limit covered further down. Capsule size also tells you nothing about strength, and strength is where labels need the closest reading.
What high strength cod liver oil means on a label
High strength cod liver oil is a description each brand chooses, and on this shelf it does not point to any fixed amount. On this shelf the words appear on products stating anything from 550mg to 2000mg of oil. Natures Aid, for example, sells a 550mg capsule as high strength.
The oil weight on the front is not the omega-3 content. Nutravita calls its 1000mg softgel high strength at 80mg EPA and 90mg DHA, the same figures printed on the Zipvit Cod Liver Oil 1000mg 120-softgel pack, whose title makes no strength claim. SuperSelf's High Strength 2000mg is two 1000mg capsules a day giving 340mg of omega-3, or 170mg per capsule.
A higher figure looks different. Healthspan Super Strength Cod Liver Oil 1,200mg states 220mg EPA and 180mg DHA per capsule, 400mg in all, and Healthspan describes it as a concentrated fish oil capsule. That is more than twice the omega-3 of a standard 1000mg cod liver oil at 170mg. There are 3 figures on the back to read instead:
- EPA and DHA in milligrams per capsule, read separately from any total omega-3 figure: Natur Supps lists 240mg of total omega-3 per capsule, of which 180mg is EPA plus DHA.
- Serving size, because some figures cover more than one capsule: Simply Supplements gives 240mg EPA and 270mg DHA per serving and calls 180 softgels a two-month supply, which is three a day.
- Vitamin A in micrograms per capsule, which decides how much room is left under the NHS daily limit.
How much vitamin A is in cod liver oil, and why it matters
Vitamin A is in every cod liver oil capsule, because fish store vitamin A in their livers. The NHS says adults aged 19 to 64 need 700 micrograms a day for men and 600 micrograms for women, and that you should be able to get all of it from your diet.
The number to hold a label against is the ceiling. The NHS advises keeping vitamin A from food and supplements combined at or below 1.5mg (1,500 micrograms) a day. Its reason is that more than that on average, over many years, may affect your bones and make them more likely to fracture in later life.
Listings on this shelf show how wide the range is. Horbaach's 1000mg capsule states 300 micrograms of vitamin A, while Lindens, Natur Supps and Transforme each claim 100% of the NRV, which UK labelling law sets at 800 micrograms. A single 800 microgram capsule is more than a woman's daily need and over half the ceiling, before any food.
Vitamin A your body does not need straight away is stored, so the totals add up over time. Many multivitamins contain vitamin A too, so add the two labels together before taking both. That stored vitamin A is also why some people are advised not to take cod liver oil at all.
Cod liver oil in pregnancy, and who else should avoid it
Cod liver oil should not be taken in pregnancy, and NHS advice on it is direct. The NHS says do not take cod liver oil or supplements containing vitamin A (sometimes called retinol) when you're pregnant, because too much vitamin A can harm your baby's development. It also advises avoiding fish liver oil supplements while trying for a baby, unless your GP advises otherwise.
NHS pregnancy advice points to other supplements instead. It recommends 400 micrograms of folic acid a day while trying to conceive and for the first 12 weeks, and 10 micrograms (400 IU) of vitamin D a day from early October to late March. For omega-3 from food, pregnant and breastfeeding women can eat oily fish, up to 2 portions a week.
Two other groups need care with vitamin A. The NHS names women who have been through the menopause and older men, who are more at risk of osteoporosis, as people who should keep to 1.5mg a day or less. It also says anyone who eats liver or liver products every week should not take supplements containing vitamin A, including fish liver oil.
If any of this applies to you, ask a pharmacist, midwife or GP before buying an omega-3 supplement. And if you mainly want omega-3 rather than vitamins A and D, cod liver oil may not be the right product, which brings in fish oil.
Cod liver oil versus fish oil: what is the difference?
The difference between cod liver oil and fish oil is the part of the fish the oil comes from. Cod is a white fish and low in fat, so its oil is pressed from the liver, which is also where fish store vitamin A. Cod liver oil labels list vitamin D as well. Fish oil usually comes from the body of oily fish and is chosen for its omega-3.
Both supply EPA and DHA, so the choice comes down to whether you want the vitamins with them. The British Dietetic Association (BDA) advises anyone considering an omega-3 supplement to choose omega-3 rather than fish liver oil, check the vitamin A content and check the label for EPA and DHA.
The BDA suggests about 450mg of EPA and DHA as a daily adult dose, the amount you would get from 1 to 2 portions of fish a week. A 1000mg cod liver oil at 170mg per capsule falls well short, and extra capsules to close the gap bring extra vitamin A too. The BDA also states that omega-3 supplements are not recommended for the UK general population, because evidence of benefit is inconclusive.
Krill oil and algal oil are the other routes: the krill oil on this shelf states 144mg EPA and 65mg DHA per 1200mg serving, and the BDA notes that algae-only supplements suit vegetarians and vegans. The cod liver oil vs fish oil comparison sets the two main options side by side. Whichever oil you pick, the capsule around it raises its own question for some diets.
Cod liver oil gelatine free: what the label means
Cod liver oil gelatine free capsules swap the standard gelatine shell for one made without gelatine, but the oil inside still comes from fish. A gelatine-free cod liver oil is therefore never vegetarian or vegan; it suits people who eat fish but avoid gelatine.
Most softgel shells are made from animal gelatine, which matters for some halal and kosher diets and for pescatarians who avoid gelatine. A gelatine-free shell removes that obstacle, but halal or kosher certification is a separate claim, so check the pack if it matters to you.
Gelatine-free options are scarce: only one listing on this shelf, Horbaach's 1241mg softgels, says it is gelatine free, and Horbaach describes it as pescatarian friendly. Its UK product page puts 1,500 micrograms of vitamin A in a daily serving of two softgels, which on its own reaches the NHS limit for food and supplements combined, and the listing gives no EPA or DHA figures. The standard vs gelatine-free cod liver oil comparison covers the trade-offs. Once the shell is settled, the last questions are how many capsules to take and how much vitamin D they give.
How many cod liver oil capsules a day, and how much vitamin D
One cod liver oil capsule a day is the dose on most packs on this shelf, and the dose printed on your pack is the one to follow. The listing for Holland & Barrett Pure Cod Liver Oil 1000mg (240 capsules), for example, says one capsule a day, preferably with a meal. A few products use larger servings, such as two capsules a day for SuperSelf.
Vitamin D is the other nutrient cod liver oil brings, and the amount varies widely. The NHS says everyone should consider 10 micrograms (400 IU) of vitamin D a day in autumn and winter, but a capsule claiming 100% of the NRV gives 5 micrograms (200 IU), half that. Horbaach's 1000mg capsule states 2.5 micrograms (100 IU), while Nature's Best states 10 micrograms (400 IU) per capsule.
If you also take a separate vitamin D supplement, count the cod liver oil in your total: the NHS says adults should not take more than 100 micrograms (4,000 IU) a day. For omega-3, food still comes first, and the NHS advice is at least 2 portions of fish a week, one of them oily, at around 140g a portion.
Everything on this shelf
16 cod liver oil products, the ones we have researched in full first.
Comparisons on this shelf
Common questions
Are cod liver oil tablets the same as capsules?
On this shelf, yes: every cod liver oil sold as a tablet or pill is a softgel capsule filled with oil. Compare them on EPA, DHA and vitamin A per capsule, as you would any other.
What is the best high strength cod liver oil?
The best is the one that states the most EPA and DHA per capsule, not the biggest milligram figure on the front. Of the listings that give per-capsule figures, Healthspan Super Strength 1,200mg is highest at 220mg EPA and 180mg DHA, though you should still check its vitamin A.
Can you take cod liver oil when pregnant?
No. The NHS says do not take cod liver oil or supplements containing vitamin A (retinol) when you're pregnant, and to avoid fish liver oil supplements while trying for a baby unless your GP advises otherwise. Ask your midwife or GP about omega-3 during pregnancy.
Is cod liver oil better than fish oil?
Neither is better for everyone. Cod liver oil adds vitamins A and D, while fish oil from the body of the fish is chosen for omega-3 alone. If a supplement is for omega-3, the BDA suggests choosing omega-3 rather than fish liver oil, and the omega-3 fish oil shelf lists the alternatives.
Is gelatine free cod liver oil vegetarian?
No. Gelatine free describes the capsule shell only, and the oil itself comes from fish. The BDA notes that algae-only omega-3 supplements are suitable for vegetarians and vegans.
How much vitamin A from cod liver oil is too much?
The NHS limit is 1.5mg (1,500 micrograms) of vitamin A a day from food and supplements combined. A capsule claiming 100% of the NRV gives 800 micrograms, so check the label and add in any multivitamin you take.
What is the purest cod liver oil?
No label term proves purity, so look for a stated purification step and contaminant testing. Solgar says the oil in Solgar Super Cod Liver Oil Complex is molecularly distilled to remove contaminants, and Simply Supplements says each batch is purity tested; both are the makers' own claims.
Is cod liver oil better than krill oil?
They are different sources rather than better or worse: krill is a small crustacean, while cod liver oil comes from fish liver and adds vitamins A and D. Compare them on EPA and DHA per serving, as the cod liver oil vs krill oil comparison does.
Sources
- NHS, Vitamin A
- NHS, Pregnancy vitamins and supplements
- NHS, Fish and shellfish
- NHS, Vitamin D
- British Dietetic Association, Omega-3: Food Fact Sheet
- legislation.gov.uk, Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Annex XIII: Reference intakes
- Horbaach UK, Cod Liver Oil Gelatine Free 1241 mg, 120 Softgels