Independent research on labels and everyday essentials. We don't earn from the links on this site. How we work
Form vs form · Cod Liver Oil

Cod Liver Oil vs Fish Oil

Both supply omega-3. Cod liver oil also brings vitamins A and D; fish oil usually brings more EPA and DHA per capsule.

Short answer

If omega-3 is what you're after, fish oil is usually the more direct route, with more EPA and DHA per capsule. Cod liver oil gives some omega-3 plus vitamins A and D, which suits people who want all three in one capsule. Don't take cod liver oil if you're pregnant, and check your total vitamin A and D if you also take a multivitamin.

At a glance

Cod liver oilFish oil (omega-3)
Made fromThe liver of the codThe flesh of oily fish
Also containsVitamins A and DUsually no significant vitamin A
Omega-3 per capsuleUsually lowerUsually higher
In pregnancyAvoidAsk your midwife or GP

Cod liver oil: what we list

Fish oil (omega-3): what we list

Compare EPA and DHA, not the "1000 mg"

Most capsules say 1,000 mg or 2,000 mg on the front. That's the weight of oil, not of omega-3. The figures that matter are EPA and DHA, which good labels print separately. On our shelf the high-strength fish oils state several hundred milligrams of EPA and DHA per serving, while typical cod liver oils state well under that.

The vitamin A question

Cod liver oil is a source of vitamin A in the form of retinol. The NHS advises not taking cod liver oil or any supplement containing vitamin A during pregnancy, because too much can harm an unborn baby. For everyone else, the issue is doubling up: a multivitamin plus cod liver oil can add up to more vitamin A and D than you meant to take.

Questions people ask

Is cod liver oil the same as omega-3?

Cod liver oil contains omega-3 but also vitamins A and D. Fish oil is the more concentrated omega-3 source.

Can I take cod liver oil when pregnant?

The NHS says not to take cod liver oil or supplements containing vitamin A (retinol) during pregnancy. Ask your midwife about an omega-3 that suits pregnancy.

Can I take cod liver oil and a multivitamin together?

Check the vitamin A and D in both first. Together they can exceed what you intended to take.

Which is better for joints?

Neither is authorised in the UK to make joint claims. EPA and DHA contribute to normal heart function, and vitamin D to normal bones, at the right doses.

Related comparisons

Browse the whole Cod Liver Oil shelf, or see every comparison.