How we work
No sponsored placements, no commission on our links, and no pretending we have lab-tested anything. Here is what we do, and what we don't.
What we look at
- The label. Dose, form, strength, serving size and how many servings are in the pack. We only use a figure when the listing states it outright; if a pack doesn't say, we show a dash rather than a guess.
- Official guidance. For supplements we check the dose against NHS advice and, where it helps, NICE or the EFSA reference intakes. Health claims are the manufacturer's, and we say so.
- The alternatives. A product is only worth recommending against what else is on the same shelf, so our research pages compare like with like: the same form, a similar dose, the same kind of buyer.
- Where to buy it. We list UK retailers that sell the exact product, as plain links.
Researched pages and basics-only pages
We have researched 358 products in full. Those pages carry our own write-up, a label reading and, where we have assessed it, a BasketLab score. Other products on our shelves are marked "Basics only": we list them so you can see the whole shelf, but we haven't written them up yet, and we would rather say so than pad the page.
Why we no longer show star ratings
We used to show the star rating and rating count from Amazon's listings. We have stopped. We could no longer keep those figures current, and a rating recorded months ago presented next to a product can mislead. Where buyer feedback says something useful, such as a common complaint about taste or capsule size, our write-up mentions it in words.
Why there are no prices on the site
Prices on everyday products change by the day, and an out-of-date price is worse than none. Rather than show figures we can't keep current, we leave prices to the retailer. Check the price, pack size and delivery cost on the retailer's own page before you buy.
The BasketLab score
On pages where we have done the editorial work, we publish our own BasketLab score out of 5. It is an evidence-and-value assessment, not a hands-on lab test, and we don't claim otherwise.
Four criteria, each scored out of 5 and averaged, rounded to one decimal place:
- Evidence. How strong the research is for the main ingredient at the dose on the label, and how consistent buyer feedback was when we assessed it.
- Value. What it cost per dose or serving against genuine alternatives at the time we assessed it, not the shelf price in isolation.
- Suitability. How cleanly it fits a defined need. Recurring caveats, such as taste or mixability, bring it down.
- Transparency. How clearly the maker states what is in it, at what strength, and what it is for. Proprietary blends with vague detail score lower.
The four component scores are shown on the page, so you can see the reasoning rather than trusting a single number. Only products we have genuinely assessed carry a score.
What we don't do
- We don't take payment for placement. Brands can't buy a spot or a kinder verdict.
- We don't earn from our links. Every retailer link on the site is a plain link.
- We don't invent figures. No made-up scores, no estimated doses, no guessed prices.
- We don't claim hands-on testing. Our verdicts come from the label, the evidence and the alternatives.
- We don't give medical advice. If you are pregnant, take medication or have a condition, check with a pharmacist or GP before starting a supplement.
How we choose what to compare
A comparison only earns a page if it is genuinely useful: two real alternatives someone would cross-shop, a real trade-off between them, and something specific to say about which suits whom. Two near-identical products from the same brand help nobody, so we don't compare them.
How we make money
At the moment we don't. There are no adverts on the site and no affiliate tracking on our links. If that changes, for example if we join a UK retailer's affiliate programme, we will say so on every page that carries such a link, and our disclosure page will set out the detail first.
Keeping it current
We cover 690 products across 62 categories, and we would rather cover fewer things properly than list everything badly. Research pages show when they were last updated.
Spotted something wrong?
Products get reformulated and listings change. If something here looks out of date or plain wrong, tell us and we'll fix it.