Wellman vs Centrum Men: Which Should You Buy?
Wellman Max is a three-part daily pack with ginseng, CoQ10 and fish oil. Centrum Men is a single multivitamin tablet. Here are the real label differences.
They aren't like for like. Wellman Max is a 3-in-1 pack: a multivitamin tablet with extras such as Siberian ginseng and CoQ10, an omega-3-6-9 fish oil capsule and a calcium and vitamin D tablet. Centrum Men is one tablet. Choose Wellman Max if you want the bigger routine and are fine with a fish oil capsule; choose Centrum Men for a simple single tablet. Never take either alongside another multivitamin.
Full look at the Wellman Tablets Wellman Max - Multivitamin Tablets → | Full look at the Centrum Multivitamin for Men, 23 Essential →
Side by side
| Wellman Tablets Wellman Max - Multivitamin Tablets | Centrum Multivitamin for Men, 23 Essential | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Wellman Tablets | Centrum |
| Our coverage | Researched in full | Basics only |
Which one is for you?
- Wellman Max suits men who want a multivitamin, omega-3-6-9 and calcium with vitamin D in one routine, and don't need a vegetarian product. Read our full look at the Wellman Tablets Wellman Max - Multivitamin Tablets →
- Centrum Men suits men who want one daily tablet with no extra capsules, and it's listed as lactose, nut, wheat and gluten free. Read our full look at the Centrum Multivitamin for Men, 23 Essential →
What you get in each pack
Wellman Max is the Max version, not the standard Wellman. Vitabiotics' page shows three daily items: a Max vitamin and mineral tablet, an Omega 3-6-9 capsule and a calcium and vitamin D tablet, taken with a main meal. A pack is 28 days.
Centrum Men is a single tablet, described as 23 nutrients including vitamins D, C and magnesium, in a 60-tablet pack. Centrum's own page gives only a few amounts: 120mg magnesium, 200mg calcium and 24mg vitamin E. It doesn't state per-tablet figures for vitamin D, B6, iron or zinc, so check the carton before comparing those numbers. Retailer listings varied on vitamin D, which is another reason to read your pack.
The extras: ginseng, CoQ10 and fish oil
The Wellman Max tablet lists Siberian ginseng extract (50mg), co-enzyme Q10 (10mg), L-carnitine (50mg), L-arginine (20mg), L-tyrosine (50mg), L-lysine (20mg), octacosanol (3mg) and citrus bioflavonoids (10mg). The omega capsule gives 400mg fish oil with 116mg of omega-3. Vitabiotics makes nutrient claims only, such as zinc contributing to normal testosterone levels, not treatment claims.
The listing for Centrum Men mentions no herbal or amino acid extras. The trade-off: Wellman Max isn't vegetarian because the capsule uses fish oil in a gelatin shell.
Doses near NHS limits
On Vitabiotics' page, the Wellman Max tablet gives 10mg of vitamin B6. The NHS says not to take more than 10mg of B6 a day in supplements unless a doctor advises it, so this sits exactly on the limit. Zinc is 15mg (NHS ceiling 25mg), vitamin A is 750µg (NHS says staying at or below 1,500µg a day from food and supplements is unlikely to cause harm) and iron is 6mg (NHS: 17mg or less is unlikely to cause harm).
Vitamin D is 15µg in the tablet plus 10µg in the calcium tablet, 25µg in total, against the NHS recommendation of 10µg and its 100µg upper limit. Because B6 is right at the ceiling, don't add a B complex or a second multivitamin. See our other options on the multivitamins shelf and the Centrum brand page below.
Who should check with a pharmacist first
Vitabiotics says Wellman Max isn't for children and advises speaking to a doctor or pharmacist if you're under medical supervision, or have epilepsy, a thyroid condition or haemochromatosis. For Centrum Men, follow the carton warnings, as Centrum's page lists none.
Browse the multivitamins shelf or the Centrum brand page. Women can see Wellwoman vs Centrum Women.
Questions people ask
Is Wellman Max better than Centrum Men?
It's different, not clearly better. Wellman Max is a three-part pack with extras like ginseng, CoQ10 and fish oil; Centrum Men is one tablet. Pick by routine and diet.
Can I take Wellman Max and Centrum Men together?
No. Doubling up multivitamins adds up vitamin B6, zinc and vitamin A. Wellman Max's B6 already equals the NHS 10mg supplement limit.
Is Wellman Max vegetarian?
No. Vitabiotics says the omega capsule contains fish oil in a gelatin shell.
How many vitamin tablets a day for Wellman Max?
One of each of the three items, with a main meal: the multivitamin tablet, the omega capsule and the calcium tablet.
Which has more vitamin D?
Wellman Max gives 25µg across its two tablets, per Vitabiotics. Centrum's page doesn't state a figure for Centrum Men, so check the carton.
Sources
- NHS, Vitamin B (B6 limit)
- NHS, Vitamin D
- Vitabiotics, Wellman Max tablets and capsules
- Centrum UK, Centrum Men
- NHS, Vitamin A
- NHS, Iron
- NHS, Others (zinc and magnesium)
Where to buy the Wellman Tablets Wellman Max - Multivitamin Tablets
Plain links to UK retailers that list this exact product. We don't earn anything from them, and prices change, so check before you buy.
Where to buy the Centrum Multivitamin for Men, 23 Essential
Plain links to UK retailers that list this exact product. We don't earn anything from them, and prices change, so check before you buy.
Browse more options in Multivitamins.