Independent research on labels and everyday essentials. We don't earn from the links on this site. How we work
Creatine · Head to head

Myprotein vs Optimum Nutrition Creatine: Which Should You Buy?

Both are plain creatine monohydrate. The differences are tub size, scoop size, flavour options and how each brand describes its testing.

Short answer

There's no difference in the active ingredient: both are creatine monohydrate, and both brands describe it as micronised. What differs is the pack. Myprotein's Impact Creatine here is a 250g tub with a 3g serving, and has flavoured options on Myprotein's own site. Optimum Nutrition's is a 317g tub with a 3.4g scoop, with flavours on its UK site too. Pick on tub size, scoop size and the testing details you care about, then take 3 to 5g a day whichever you choose.

Full look at the Myprotein Impact Creatine Monohydrate Powder → | Full look at the Optimum Nutrition Micronised Creatine Monohydrate Powder, 317g →

Side by side

Myprotein Impact Creatine Monohydrate PowderOptimum Nutrition Micronised Creatine Monohydrate Powder, 317g
BrandMyproteinOptimum Nutrition
On the label250 g tub317 g tub
Our coverageResearched in fullResearched in full

Which one is for you?

Is Myprotein creatine the same as Optimum Nutrition creatine?

In substance, yes. Both are creatine monohydrate, the form the International Society of Sports Nutrition (ISSN) position stand calls the most effective ergogenic supplement available to athletes. The listing for Myprotein Impact Creatine describes it as micronised, with 3g per serving and about 83 servings in the 250g tub. The listing for Optimum Nutrition Micronised Creatine gives a 317g tub, one scoop of 3.4g creatine monohydrate that ON says provides 3g of creatine, and about 93 servings.

Micronised means the powder is milled finer so it mixes more easily. It changes texture, not the dose.

How do tub size and scoop size compare?

Myprotein's tub is 250g and ON's is 317g, so ON's pack is larger. Scoops differ too: Myprotein's own product page currently says to mix 3.4g (about one scoop), while the listing describes a 3g serving, so check the tub you receive. ON's UK page also lists 3.4g of creatine monohydrate per serving, and says each serving provides 3g of creatine.

That's why serving counts mislead. At a steady 5g a day, the Myprotein tub gives about 50 servings and the ON tub about 63. ON's UK site also lists 187g and 634g sizes of the same powder, and Myprotein's page lists a range of pack sizes, so size isn't fixed to one tub.

Flavours, testing and allergens

Both listings here are unflavoured. Myprotein's site also lists Berry Burst, Blue Raspberry, Tropical, Vimto and Chupa Chups Watermelon Lollipop options, and ON's UK site lists Fruit Punch, Blue Raspberry and Orange. Flavoured versions are different products, so check their labels.

On testing, Myprotein's page mentions Informed Choice certification, a banned-substance testing scheme, and ON's UK page doesn't mention a testing scheme for this tub. Neither page mentions Creapure, a branded German creatine. If third-party testing matters to you, for example in drug-tested sport, confirm the scheme on the pack of the exact tub, as certification can differ by product and batch. Myprotein says it's produced in a facility that also handles milk, and ON says its tub may contain milk, soy, gluten, egg, nuts and peanuts. ON says it's not suitable for under-18s.

How much creatine should you take?

The ISSN position stand says creatine stores can generally be maintained by ingesting 3 to 5g a day, and describes a loading protocol of about 0.3g per kg of body weight a day for 5 to 7 days as an option. Either scoop gets you into that range, though a 3g scoop is the lower end. The Great Britain claims register allows the claim that creatine increases physical performance in successive bursts of short-term, high-intensity exercise at 3g a day, for adults.

If you're comparing tub sizes more generally, see our 250g vs 500g creatine comparison, or the other powders on our creatine shelf.

Questions people ask

Which is better, Myprotein or Optimum Nutrition creatine?

They're the same ingredient, creatine monohydrate. Choose on tub size (250g vs 317g), scoop size and flavour options, and check the testing scheme on the pack if that matters to you.

Is Myprotein creatine the same as ON creatine?

Both are creatine monohydrate and both brands describe the powder as micronised. They differ in tub size, scoop size and flavour range.

How much creatine is in one scoop?

The Myprotein listing says 3g per serving, though its site gives a 3.4g scoop. ON's scoop is 3.4g of creatine monohydrate, which ON says provides 3g of creatine.

How much creatine should I take a day?

3 to 5g a day is the common maintenance amount in the ISSN position stand. Loading isn't required.

Can I use either under 18?

ON says its creatine isn't suitable for under-18s, and under-18s should check with a GP or pharmacist before any creatine.

Is either Creapure?

Neither Myprotein's nor ON's UK product page mentions Creapure. If that matters to you, look for it on the label.

Sources

Where to buy the Myprotein Impact Creatine Monohydrate Powder

Where to buy

Plain links to UK retailers that list this exact product. We don't earn anything from them, and prices change, so check before you buy.

Where to buy the Optimum Nutrition Micronised Creatine Monohydrate Powder, 317g

Where to buy

Plain links to UK retailers that list this exact product. We don't earn anything from them, and prices change, so check before you buy.

Browse more options in Creatine.