Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser vs Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak: Which Should You Buy?
Two poo-bag giants with a quarter-million reviews each, split by price and eco-credentials.
A proper head-to-head, both with well over 200,000 reviews. Amazon Basics gives you 300 lavender-scented, leak-proof bags for £8.91, roughly 3p a bag, at a solid 4.7. Earth Rated is dearer at £11.49, but leans on extra-thick, guaranteed-leak-proof bags made from 65% recycled plastic, and pips the rating at 4.8. For a daily rebuy the per-bag pennies barely differ once you factor pack sizes, so it comes down to priorities. Want the cheapest reliable bag, Amazon Basics wins on maths. Care about thickness and recycled content, and the small Earth Rated premium buys a greener bag.
Full look at the Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser → | Full look at the Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak →
Amazon Basics Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser, Lavender, 300
Earth Rated Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak Proof and
Side by side
| Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser | Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.6 | ★★★★★ 4.7 |
| Review count | 5,424 | 231,854 |
| Brand | Amazon Basics | Earth Rated |
| Highlights |
|
|
Which one is for you?
- Buy the Amazon Basics bags if you want the cheapest reliable, leak-proof, lavender-scented poo bags by the hundred. Read our full look at the Amazon Basics Dog Poop/Waste Bags without Dispenser →
- Buy the Earth Rated bags if you want extra-thick, recycled-plastic bags and don't mind paying a little more. Read our full look at the Earth Rated Dog Poo Bags, Guaranteed Leak →
Prices are pulled live from Amazon.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding.
Browse more options in Dog Essentials or see the whole Pet Essentials department.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.